Autoship Service

Autoship - Autosave

  • With autoship, discounts are applied on top of on-going sales (exceptions apply). Choose your delivery schedule and know you’re always getting the best deal.

Easy to Manage Payments

  • Need to change to a different card? Easily switch between payment profiles for your subscription within Payment Options your account.
  • Be notified for any payment issues or impending card expirations.

You're in Control

  1. We'll notify you days in advance of your upcoming shipment.
  2. You may delay the shipment right from email reminder.
  3. Stock level running low? Send your shipment early right from your susbcription manager.
Learn More

Cat Plush Toys

Treat your feline friend to the ultimate blend of comfort and fun with our plush cat toys. Soft, cuddly, and irresistibly charming, these toys are perfect for cats who love to snuggle as much as they enjoy a playful pounce. Whether your kitty wants a companion for quiet nap time or an exciting toy for swatting and batting, these plush toys are up for the task. Our cat plush toys are designed to provide both comfort and entertainment.

82 items

Set Ascending Direction
  1. ZippyClaws Burrow - Mice N Cheese
    ZippyClaws Burrow - Mice N Cheese
    List Price: $16.99 Our Price: $12.99 Our Price: $12.99 You Save: $4.00 (24%)
  2. Smartykat Bendy Buddy Bendable Catnip Toy for Cats
    Smartykat Bendy Buddy Bendable Catnip Toy for Cats
    List Price: $9.49 Our Price: $8.49 Our Price: $8.49 You Save: $1.00 (11%)
  3. Fringe Petshop Cat Toy - Clownin' Around
    Fringe Petshop Cat Toy - Clownin' Around
    Our Price: $9.99
  4. PetStages Cuddle Pal Plush Unicorn Cat Toy
    PetStages Cuddle Pal Plush Unicorn Cat Toy
    Our Price: $15.99
  5. PetStages Hide & Seek Fish Bowl Cat Puzzle Toy
    PetStages Hide & Seek Fish Bowl Cat Puzzle Toy
    Our Price: $23.99
  6. Mad Cat Narwhal Silvervine Stick Cat Toy
    Mad Cat Narwhal Silvervine Stick Cat Toy
    List Price: $11.99 Our Price: $10.99 Our Price: $10.99 You Save: $1.00 (8%)
  7. Coastal Turbo Tail Rattle Mouse Cat Toy
    Coastal Turbo Tail Rattle Mouse Cat Toy
    List Price: $7.99 Our Price: $7.49 Our Price: $7.49 You Save: $0.50 (6%)
  8. HugSmart Meow Buddies for Cats - Camping Claws Cat S'mores
    HugSmart Meow Buddies for Cats - Camping Claws Cat S'mores
    Our Price: $11.99
  9. PetStages Wiggle Worm Flopping Cat Toy
    PetStages Wiggle Worm Flopping Cat Toy
    Our Price: $22.99
  10. KONG Refillables Catnip Beaver
    KONG Refillables Beaver Catnip Cat Toy
    List Price: $10.99 Our Price: $9.49 Our Price: $9.49 You Save: $1.50 (14%)
  11. Kong Refillables Catnip Rat Cat Toy
    KONG Refillables Rat Catnip Cat Toy
    List Price: $10.99 Our Price: $9.49 Our Price: $9.49 You Save: $1.50 (14%)
  12. Huxley & Kent Plush Mewow Cake
    Huxley & Kent Plush Mewow Cake
    List Price: $10.99 Our Price: $8.99 Our Price: $8.99 You Save: $2.00 (18%)
  13. Fabcat Sushi Pieces Cat Toy
    Fabcat Sushi Pieces
    Our Price: $12.99
  14. ZippyClaws Burrow - Fish In Bowl
    ZippyClaws Burrow - Fish In Bowl
    List Price: $16.99 Our Price: $12.99 Our Price: $12.99 You Save: $4.00 (24%)
  15. ZippyClaws Burrow - Snakes In Cactus
    ZippyClaws Burrow - Snakes In Cactus
    List Price: $16.99 Our Price: $12.99 Our Price: $12.99 You Save: $4.00 (24%)
  16. ZippyClaws NomNomz - Pizza and Cola
    ZippyClaws NomNomz - Pizza and Cola
    List Price: $9.49 Our Price: $7.99 Our Price: $7.99 You Save: $1.50 (16%)
  17. Smartykat Chit Chatter with Feathers & Sound Toy for Cats
    Smartykat Chit Chatter with Feathers & Sound Toy for Cats
    List Price: $20.49 Our Price: $18.49 Our Price: $18.49 You Save: $2.00 (10%)
  18. Smartykat Silly Swimmers Plush Catnip 2Pk Toy for Cats
    Smartykat Silly Swimmers Plush Catnip 2Pk Toy for Cats
    List Price: $13.49 Our Price: $11.99 Our Price: $11.99 You Save: $1.50 (11%)
  19. PetStages Pawrty Catnip Cat Toys - 3 Pack
    PetStages Pawrty Catnip Cat Toys - 3 Pack
    Our Price: $14.49
  20. PetStages Festival Themed Catnip Cat Toys - 3 Pack
    PetStages Festival Themed Catnip Cat Toys - 3 Pack
    Our Price: $14.49
  21. PetStages Kitty Sweet Treats Cat Toys - 6 Pack
    PetStages Kitty Sweet Treats Cat Toys - 6 Pack
    Our Price: $20.99
  22. PetStages Purrsecco & Cupcakes Cat Toys - 6 Pack
    PetStages Purrsecco & Cupcakes Cat Toys - 6 Pack
    Our Price: $20.99
  23. Coastal Turbo Ameba Bug Cat Toy
    Coastal Turbo Tail Ameba Bug Cat Toy
    List Price: $6.99 Our Price: $6.49 Our Price: $6.49 You Save: $0.50 (7%)
  24. Coastal Turbo Tail Crinkle Mouse with Catnip Pouch Cat Toy
    Coastal Turbo Tail Crinkle Mouse with Catnip Pouch Cat Toy
    List Price: $11.99 Our Price: $10.99 Our Price: $10.99 You Save: $1.00 (8%)
  25. Fringe Petshop Happy Purr-thday Cat Toy
    Fringe Petshop Happy Purr-thday Cat Toy
    Our Price: $18.99
  26. HugSmart Meow Buddies for Cats - Camping Claws Meow Camps
    HugSmart Meow Buddies for Cats - Camping Claws Meow Camps
    Our Price: $15.99
  27. KONG Kitten Kickeroo
    KONG Kitten Kickeroo
    List Price: $8.99 Our Price: $7.49 Our Price: $7.49 You Save: $1.50 (17%)
  28. Mad Cat Cat Toy - Chicken and Waffles
    Mad Cat Cat Toy - Chicken and Waffles
    List Price: $15.49 Our Price: $14.49 Our Price: $14.49 You Save: $1.00 (6%)
  29. AFP Mod Cat Feather Snake - Green
    AFP Mod Cat Feather Snake
    Our Price: $7.99
  30. Mad Cat Cat Toy - Sweet Gnome
    Mad Cat Cat Toy - Sweet Gnome
    List Price: $15.49 Our Price: $14.49 Our Price: $14.49 You Save: $1.00 (6%)
  31. Mad Cat Cat Toy - Mewnicorn
    Mad Cat Cat Toy - Mewnicorn
    List Price: $18.49 Our Price: $17.99 Our Price: $17.99 You Save: $0.50 (3%)
  32. KONG Cat Wubba Caticorn
    KONG Cat Wubba Caticorn
    List Price: $13.99 Our Price: $12.99 Our Price: $12.99 You Save: $1.00 (7%)
  33. KONG Better Buzz Bee
    KONG Better Buzz Bee
    List Price: $9.49 Our Price: $8.49 Our Price: $8.49 You Save: $1.00 (11%)
  34. Huxley & Kent Plush Kitty Klaw
    Huxley & Kent Plush Kitty Klaw
    List Price: $10.99 Our Price: $8.99 Our Price: $8.99 You Save: $2.00 (18%)
  35. Huxley & Kent Plush Whisker's Whiskey
    Huxley & Kent Plush Whisker's Whiskey
    List Price: $10.99 Our Price: $8.99 Our Price: $8.99 You Save: $2.00 (18%)
  36. Fabcat Sushi Roll Cat Toy
    Fabcat Sushi Rolls
    Our Price: $12.99

Product has been added to cart

Page
per page

Cat Plush Toys FAQs


Are plush toys safe for cats to play with?


Yes, plush toys are generally safe for cats to play with as long as they do not have any small parts that can be chewed off and swallowed. Supervising your cat while they play with plush toys is important to ensure they do not ingest any part of the toy.


Can plush toys help with a cat's anxiety?


Plush toys can provide comfort to cats and help reduce anxiety. They can mimic the feeling of a mother cat's fur and provide a sense of security for the cat.


How do I clean my cat's plush toys?


Most plush toys are machine washable. Check the label for care instructions. Use a gentle, fragrance-free detergent and wash in cold water. Air-dry the toy completely before giving it back to your cat.


Can plush toys help keep my cat entertained?


Yes, plush toys can be a fun and entertaining way to keep your cat occupied. They can also help satisfy a cat's natural hunting and pouncing instincts.


What types of plush toys are best for cats?


Plush toys that are soft, lightweight, and easy to carry are best for cats. Some cats prefer toys that resemble prey, such as mice or birds, while others may prefer toys with catnip or interactive toys like those that can be filled with treats.


How often should I replace my cat's plush toys?


It is a good idea to regularly inspect your cat's plush toys for signs of wear and tear. Replace any toys that have holes or are falling apart to prevent your cat from accidentally ingesting any part of the toy.


Shop Cat Plush Toys


Whether your cat loves to chase, pounce, chew, or just cuddle, plush toys for cats are always a feline favourite. They are lightweight and come in a variety of fun shapes to ensure safe play.


Most cat households have a variety of toys to keep their cats entertained. When choosing toys for young kittens or cats that don't have much experience with toys, start with something small and simple like the Multipet Pizza Plush Cat Toy. This lightweight toy contains catnip to encourage chasing, batting, and catching.


For cats that prefer to get rough with their stuff, the Smartykat Kolossal Karrot is a great choice. This unique kicker toy is large and durable so your cat can kick with the full force of their powerful bunny legs. Enhanced with catnip and crinkle materials to further engage your cat's senses.


Some cats just can't get enough of the nip — Catnip that is. This is why the Kong Refillables Plus Toys are the perfect way to keep your cat interested and encourage more playtime. Shop these and many more popular cat toys such as teasers wands and cat puzzle toys for a complete play routine for your favourite feline at Homes Alive Pets.